Insights

Analysis, insights and research from Louisbourg Investments.

The S&P 500’s Uneven Surge: Mag7 and the other 493 stocks

a hand hold a phone with stocks with a laptop and tablet looking at stocks

As the US stock market navigates a remarkable bull run fueled by tech giants, the road ahead presents both opportunities and serious challenges that could reshape its trajectory.

The United States stock market – the S&P 500 – is at a crossroads after coming off a bull run marked by back-to-back years of  > 20% returns. This remarkable performance has been largely driven by the Magnificent 7, or “Mag7” tech giants, creating a notable divergence between the market cap-weighted S&P 500 and its equal-weighted counterpart – a phenomenon that highlights both the market’s strength and its potential vulnerabilities. For context, the S&P 500 returned 25% in 2024. 13% of that return is attributable to the Mag7 (5% for NVDIA alone), with the remaining 493 stocks comprising of the other 12%.

The market’s impressive trajectory reflects genuine strengths in the American economy. US productivity growth has outpaced other developed nations, powered by technological innovation and an entrepreneurial environment. The possibility of continued business-friendly policies, including deregulation and tax incentives, could further stimulate domestic production and investment. Additionally, the labor market has shown remarkable resilience, with job openings remaining above pre-pandemic levels despite recent cooling.

However, several significant challenges loom on the horizon.

Perhaps most pressing is the issue of government spending and debt. Federal debt has swelled to approximately 120% of GDP, up from a once-manageable 60%. This expansion, driven by responses to the 2008 financial crisis, 2017 tax cuts, and COVID-19 spending, creates mounting pressure as interest rates rise. The cost of refinancing this debt at higher rates threatens to strain the federal budget severely, potentially forcing difficult fiscal choices in the near future. Obviously, Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE, aims to curb this, but time will tell how effective they can be.

Inflation adds another layer of complexity. The primary inflationary pressure right now is shelter. Currently CPI measures are lagging the lower real-time measures like Zillow’s Observed Rent Index (ZORI). This paints an optimistic picture of declining inflationary pressures. However, potential policy shifts could reignite these concerns. Particularly worrying are the implications of aggressive trade policies, especially regarding countries like Canada, Taiwan, and China that supply essential commodities, semiconductors, and core goods to the US. Any disruption to these trade relationships could trigger supply chain issues and price increases.

The nation also faces a looming energy challenge. Electricity consumption is projected to increase, driven by the rapid expansion of data centers supporting artificial intelligence applications and the growing adoption of electric vehicles. The current energy infrastructure will struggle to meet this demand, particularly as the country transitions toward cleaner but often more expensive energy sources. While nuclear power offers a promising solution, political obstacles to expanding energy supply remain significant.

Despite these challenges, the market’s strength shouldn’t be dismissed.

The concentration of returns in technology stocks reflects genuine technological advancement and innovation, particularly in artificial intelligence. However, prudent investors should approach this environment with a balanced perspective. Historical data suggests that attempting to time the market based on macroeconomic indicators often leads to suboptimal results – selling too early and buying back too late.

The path forward requires a nuanced understanding of these competing forces.

Given President-elect Trump’s tendency to change policies on a dime, the situation will remain fluid. While the US possesses fundamental strengths that could sustain growth, the challenges of mounting government debt, potential inflation, and energy constraints demand attention. Rather than making dramatic portfolio shifts based on short-term predictions, investors would be wise to maintain focus on long-term financial objectives and risk-reward principles. This approach acknowledges both the opportunities and risks present in today’s market while avoiding the pitfalls of reactive investing.

Picture of Robert Currie

Robert Currie

Robert Currie, CFA is an Associate Portfolio Manager with Louisbourg Investments. Comments or questions may be submitted to Robert at robert.currie@louisbourg.net

This writing is for general information purposes only. It is not intended to provide legal, accounting, tax or financial advice. For complex matter you should always seek help from a professional. Any opinions expressed are my own and may not reflect those of Louisbourg Investments.

WHAT WE OFFER

Institutional Investors
We recognize that each institution possesses unique financial goals and challenges. We take a customized approach, collaborating closely with stakeholders to construct flexible, bespoke investment strategies and service models aligned with their specific objectives, ultimately fostering their financial prosperity.
Private Wealth
Building wealth demands diligence and determination, values that our team embodies daily. Our focus extends to families and private individuals, where we craft personalized portfolios and plans tailored to bring stability, foster growth, and transform your financial aspirations into reality. We are committed to helping you achieve your financial goals.